If you are going on the cheap, then use newspaper. It is readily available and you can ask neighbors to save it for you. You don't want the ads or inserts (the slick glossy stuff). It doesn't mold well. Just the regular newspaper. My recommendation is to use some disposable gloves when you wrap with it because otherwise your hands get black with the ink that rubs off.
Also, do NOT wrap white dishes with newspaper. The ink will rub off on the dishes and you will have hours of scrubbing time to clean them.
Packing paper has more body to it than newspaper and will stand up to more than one use. It also is a little heavier so often one sheet is enough whereas with newspaper I would use two or three sheets.
Packing paper is readily available at all the DIY stores or Moving specialty stores such as U Haul at a reasonable cost. The sheets are a standard size 24 x 30 inch although you can find a larger one also. It can be torn in half lengthwise for wrapping smaller items.
U Haul packing paper
I use lots of this -- probably 2000 - 3000 sheets of this for the entire house. Use it for:
- Wrapping dishes and glasses
- Wrapping knick knacks and collectables
- Cushioning empty spaces in all your boxes so you don't get shifting
- To line tops and bottoms of boxes that don't seal tight to keep out dust
Bubble wrap comes in three sizes of bubbles (although the medium size is a little harder to find) and different width rolls. The narrowed width rolls (12 "K) are usually fine for dishes and small breakables. The wider rolls will be needed for artwork and framed photos.
I use the large bubble for large items, the small bubbles for small items. There is also an anti-static version that is for electronics. I will use that on those items where we don't have the original boxes but I do try to save the original boxes for printers, computers, TVs etc. It all depends on how much storage room you have.
Shop around for bubble wrap, or save it from items you get sent to you. I buy the large rolls of both sizes. I found Staples to have the best price around me for in store pick up.
Staples large bubble 100 ft. roll
When do I use bubble wrap vs. paper?
Paper is fine for everyday dishes and items you can easily replace. I use bubble wrap on my precious china, antique glass and china and silver tea sets, for example (not the flatware).
Foam sleeves, Rolls of Foam, and Styrofoam Peanuts
The foam sleeves can be handy but they are pretty expensive on a per sleeve basis. I do like the pink version for the non-static applications on my electronics. The foam rolls are better for larger or unusually shaped items. Best for electronics are the original boxes and packing material they came in -- especially for printers and scanners. I actually will not ship the electronics with the moving company anyway; those all go in the car with me.
Styrofoam peanuts are great for filling around odd shaped items inside boxes. For example, lamps or breakable art objects, even things like breakable pitchers I will wrap in bubble wrap, then place in a box and backfill with peanuts.

